People use social media platforms for various purposes, including connecting with others, entertainment, and sharing information. For some, content creation is a full-time job. Spending on influencer marketing has been rising since 2019, and content creation on social media platforms is becoming an increasingly popular way to make a living (Insider Intelligence). The monetary incentive may impact the authenticity of creators, which users must be aware of. These content creators, also referred to as influencers, can make money in several ways on TikTok including sponsored content, the TikTok Creator Marketplace, the Creator Rewards Program, and TikTok Live (How Can Creators Monetize on TikTok?). Sponsors may select creators based on many factors, including the number of views and followers a creator has, or the style of the content they produce. Sponsors’ selection of creators could be influenced by biases, which could impact the diversity of perspectives on a product. As influencers continue to produce sponsored content, users should consider how monetary incentives affect this content and reflect on the diversity of perspectives they are consuming.
Data from (U.S. Influencer Marketing Spend | Statista). The graph above shows how the influencer marketing industry is growing in the United States. Spending in the industry increased from 2.42 billion dollars to 7.14 billion dollars (195%) in 5 years.
While sponsorships can be great business opportunities for creators, they can impact their authenticity. The motivation of revenue may lead creators to promote products that they would otherwise not use themselves or to partner with brands whose values they may not align with (Hofstetter and Gollnhofer). In falsely endorsing these products, influencers can mislead viewers about their quality. Is Charli D’Amelio truly “obsessed with CeraVe and their new shampoo,” or is she being paid to have that opinion (D’amelio, Charli @charlidamelio)? Videos like this, in which creators heavily praise a product, can raise red flags about authenticity.
Video complied by Caroline Foley with videos from: (McCain, Jared (@jaredmccain))(Beck, Noah @noahbeck) (D’amelio, Charli @charlidamelio)(Shane, Jake @octopusslover8)(Earle, Alix @alixearle)(Bader, Remi @remibader). This video displays the different marketing techniques that content creators use to advertise products.
Inauthenticity is not always easy to spot, especially when viewers have an established sense of trust with creators. The value of creators’ opinions on products lies in their connection with their audience (Alcántara-Pilar et al.). Influencers weave personal narratives into their content to resonate with their audience on a personal level (10). In doing so, influencers cultivate connection and trust. In the video above, Jake Shane states, “Yes, my toothbrush is a little dirty, but who’s isn’t?” in his ad for Laneige (Shane, Jake @octopusslover8). In mentioning his dirty toothbrush, Shane is attempting to relate to his viewers. Establishing a sense of connection and emotional resonance has a positive effect on how users perceive an influencer’s expertise and positively affects their purchase intentions (Alcántara-Pilar et al.). As Shane relates to his viewers, they are more likely to agree with his opinions, such as his approval of the Laneige serum. This influence makes creators like Jake Shane attractive to brands for sponsorships.
Sponsored content can take many forms, and creators use a variety of marketing strategies to influence viewers. Some creators use product placement, like Noah Beck subtly placing a can of Celsius on the counter in his dancing video (Beck). Others showcase themselves consuming the product, like Charli D’Amelio, Jake Shane, and Remi Bader (D’Amelio; Shane; Bader). Influencers also use a more direct approach, like Jared McCain and Alix Earl, who explicitly encouraged viewers to make a purchase (McCain; Earle). While influencers have creative liberty in the production of sponsored content, the disclosure of this content is regulated. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) works to prevent deceptive advertising. The agency requires that social media influencers disclose sponsorships to users when they are receiving something of value in exchange for mentioning a product (“Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers”). If a creator fails to do so, they risk legal action from the FTC. There are many ways creators can disclose a sponsorship on the TikTok app, including using the #ad or placing the “paid partnership” label on videos.
Although content creators are required to disclose their sponsorships, they do not always do so. While some are simply unaware of the guidelines set by the FTC, some influencers intentionally disregard them. Reto Hofstetter and Johanna Gollnhofer conducted a study on the tensions between authenticity and monetization in social media by interviewing creators with over one million followers. One of the creators stated, “From my experience, once TikTok knows that you’re advertising a product, say you’re advertising AirPods, the followership goes down,” which indicates that there is an incentive for creators to disguise sponsored videos (Hofstetter and Gollnhofer 432). If users believe a creator has ulterior motives, they will lose trust in them and will be less inclined to engage with the creator’s content. For this reason, influencers may use marketing strategies that distract viewers from their marketing objective, and users must pay close attention to identify sponsored content.
While it is often easy to spot sponsored content, like D’Amelio’s video for CeraVe and Jared McCain’s video for the NBA Shop on Amazon, it is not always that obvious (D’Amelio; McCain). Looking for #ad or the “paid partnership” label is the easiest way to confirm if content is sponsored. Users can also look for common signs like an overcomplimentary tone, prominent product placement, or a call-to-action. Once a user has successfully identified sponsored content they should view it from a skeptical perspective.
Users should take the extra step to form their own opinion on a product before accepting an influencer’s perspective. Jake Shane asserts that the Laneige Bouncy and Firm Serum “can help protect your skin’s bounce and glow,” but is that true (Shane,Jake @octopusslover8)? A quick Google search will reveal that the product has an average rating of 4.9/5 on the Sephora website. Additionally, the majority of the serum’s reviews praise its effectiveness, confirming Shane’s opinion (“LANEIGE Bouncy & Firm Radiance Boosting Serum with Peony & Collagen Complex”). While Shane’s opinion was supported by an additional source, this may not be the case for all influencers. Investigation may reveal that an influencer is giving a product false praise, which is why it is always important for users to do their research. This research can be as thorough as users see necessary, which in most cases may be a simple 20-second Google search as outlined above.
It is also important to consider the is the demographics of paid influencers. I recently watched a video on TikTok that asked viewers if they follow any black content creators (Roberts, Sheron @theroberts2.0). After reflecting on the video, I realized that most of the content creators on my For You Page are white. This made me question whether this is due to the For You Page algorithm or if black content creators have fewer opportunities for sponsorships.
The data above is from the Racial and Gender Inequalities Influencer Report 2022 (Hub). The chart displays that nearly 2/3 of the influencers from the study believe that social media platforms ask moderators to suppress the content of creators based on their nationalities, political views, disabilities, and socioeconomic classes.
I looked into this issue and found a study on the experiences of black content creators on TikTok. The report details how black content creators across social media platforms have identified problems of discrimination (Harris et al.). According to the report, these problems are perpetuated by users, companies that sponsor creators, and the platforms’ algorithms, which suggests there are multiple problems at play. Unfortunately, bias related to the algorithm cannot be confirmed without internal access to TikTok’s programming, and thus, the study focused on creators’ perceptions of the algorithm. Many black creators in the study believe that the algorithm suppresses their content from users’ feeds. One participant stated that they don’t think users will see black creators on their For You Page unless they are sought out:
[I] don’t think unless you’re … actively searching out those videos, or only liking videos of Black people, you’re not gonna see them on your For You Page, even if they’re doing similar or the exact same thing that the white content creator counterparts are also doing (Harris et al.).
The creators attributed this problem with the algorithm to several possible causes, including racism from either developers or users whose data is used as input for the algorithm. Regardless of the explanation, if black creators receive fewer views, they are disadvantaged in receiving sponsorship opportunities. Further, the study references that many black content creators have reported ‘lowball’ offers for sponsored content (Harris et al.). This indicates that there is both a problem with the platform itself and the companies providing sponsorship opportunities. Both parties are placing black content creators at a disadvantage in succeeding as influencers and reinforcing systemic biases that prioritize certain voices over others.
Why does this matter for viewers? If brands are prioritizing White influencers, many users may not be gaining perspectives on products that are reflective of their own identities. A lack of diverse perspectives does not tell users about a product’s effectiveness across demographics. For example, if a makeup product is only promoted by white influencers, it may be difficult for black users to gain an understanding of how well the product will work on their skin tone. This problem applies not only to black people but to all marginalized groups, including other racial minorities and disabled people (Hub). Users can seek to mitigate the effects of this bias in the content creation industry by actively seeking out and interacting with minority perspectives on TikTok. Boosting the engagement of minority creators will put them in a better position to receive sponsorship deals, which could lead the For You Page to become more reflective of the diversity of users’ perspectives.
Sponsorship deals can be a great economic opportunity for both brands and creators, but these sponsorships can impact the authenticity of creators’ content. The incentive of monetary gain can lead influencers to share false praise and opinions. Users must be conscious of these incentives and should perform additional research before accepting an influencer’s opinion and making a purchasing decision. Additionally, users must be aware that sponsorship initiatives may lack diverse perspectives. The opinion of one influencer may not be representative of how a product will be perceived across a population. Users can actively seek out diverse perspectives and engage with diverse creators to help combat this issue. While this discussionfocuses on TikTok, this is a vast problem that extends to all social media platforms. As marketing spending on influencers continues to increase across platforms, so must user awareness.
Works Cited
Alcántara-Pilar, Juan Miguel, et al. “From Likes to Loyalty: Exploring the Impact of Influencer Credibility on Purchase Intentions in TikTok.” Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, vol. 78, May 2024, p. 103709. ScienceDirect, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretconser.2024.103709.
Earle, Alix @alixearle. “Needing to Stock My Fridge with All the Minis Now @Drink Poppi @Walmart #poppipartner.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@alixearle/video/7481346346620898590?_r=1&_t=ZT-8ujlFYSEQ62. Accessed 12 Apr. 2025.
D’amelio, Charli @charlidamelio. I’m a Head of CeraVe Now 🤍 i’ve Been Using @CeraVe for Years on My Skin, and Scalp Care Is Actually Skin Care Too. i Think This New Title Calls for a New Dress… #CeraVePartner. https://www.tiktok.com/@charlidamelio/video/7473515982678543658?_t=ZT-8ujl7G8EUxS&_r=1. Accessed 30 Mar. 2025.
“Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers.” Federal Trade Commission, 24 Oct. 2019, https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/disclosures-101-social-media-influencers.
Harris, Camille, et al. “‘Honestly, I Think TikTok Has a Vendetta Against Black Creators’: Understanding Black Content Creator Experiences on TikTok.” Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, vol. 7, no. CSCW2, Sept. 2023, pp. 1–31. DOI.org (Crossref), https://doi.org/10.1145/3610169.
Hofstetter, Reto, and Johanna Franziska Gollnhofer. “The Creator’s Dilemma: Resolving Tensions between Authenticity and Monetization in Social Media.” International Journal of Research in Marketing, vol. 41, no. 3, Sept. 2024, pp. 427–35. ScienceDirect, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijresmar.2024.07.001.
“How Can Creators Monetize on TikTok?” TikTok Help Center, https://support.tiktok.com/en/using-tiktok/growing-your-audience/how-can-creators-earn-on-tiktok. Accessed 30 Mar. 2025.
Hub, Influencer Marketing. “Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI) in Influencer Marketing: Racial and Gender Inequalities Report.” Influencer Marketing Hub, 14 Oct. 2022, https://influencermarketinghub.com/dei-influencer-marketing-report/.
Insider Intelligence. U.S. Influencer Marketing Spend | Statista. July 2022, https://www.statista.com/statistics/1254039/influencer-marketing-spending-usa/.
Shane, Jake @octopusslover8. “AD Morning in My Life on Tour ✨ @laneige_us #laneige_partner.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@octopusslover8/video/7481076864644042030?_t=ZT-8ujlOR6a5Na&_r=1. Accessed 12 Apr. 2025.
McCain, Jared (@jaredmccain). “NBA Tip Off Is Just around the Corner, Who’s Ready?!?! @Amazon Influencer Program @Amazon.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@jaredmccain/video/7428234137430936875. Accessed 30 Mar. 2025.
“LANEIGE Bouncy & Firm Radiance Boosting Serum with Peony & Collagen Complex.” Sephora, https://www.sephora.com/product/bouncy-firm-radiance-boosting-serum-w-peony-collagen-complextm-P515338. Accessed 2 Apr. 2025.
Beck, Noah @noahbeck. “‘Look Im Not a Dancer…’🧎♂️😫 @CelsiusOfficial #CELSIUSbrandpartner.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@noahbeck/video/7462488824099425582?_t=ZT-8ujm6tApfKA&_r=1. Accessed 12 Apr. 2025.
Bader, Remi @remibader. “Celebrating Valentine’s Day Alone: A Personal Reflection.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@remibader/video/7470940424883014955. Accessed 12 Apr. 2025.
Roberts, Sheron @theroberts2.0. “Not Sure If This Video Will Even Get to You, but Doing a Little Field Survey on How the Algorithm Shares out Content and What Biases Play into That #blackcontentcreator #swifties #pilates #fyp #fashiontiktok #revolve #sabrinacarpenter #tiktokcreator #creatorinsights.” TikTok, https://www.tiktok.com/@sotorho/video/7477578468109143338?_t=ZT-8ufJRQOfu4U&_r=1. Accessed 15 Apr. 2025.